Best Non Toxic Eyeshadow

What is the safest eyeshadow? Check out these non toxic eyeshadow options that will eliminate chemical ingredients from your makeup routine.

Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we may earn commissions from qualifying purchases from Amazon.

Table of Contents

Can eyeshadow be toxic?

Eyeshadows are available in so many beautiful colors and shades, but many are made from ingredients that can be harmful to our health.

Carcinogenic ingredients do not belong in any products that go on our skin, especially since our skin absorbs 60% of what we put on it in 26 seconds! And for an area as sensitive as the eyes, we ESPECIALLY do not need toxic ingredients in our makeup.

Top brand eyeshadows include toxic ingredients like propylparaben (and other parabens), dyes like black no. 2, blue no. 1, red no. 40), talc, fragrance, quaternium-15, phenoxyethanol, and more.

These ingredients are known to be linked to cancer, skin, eye, and respiratory irritation, allergies, organ toxicity, endocrine disruption, ecotoxicology, and harm to the reproductive system.

Still not conviced? Read this:

“According to Harvard research, mainstream cosmetic products, such as mascara, eye shadow, eyeliner & eye makeup remover typically contain preservatives to prevent microbial growth. The concentrations approved for consumer use are toxic to human ocular surface & adnexal cells.” [Read the rest of the article here.]

What is the saftest eyeshadow? NON TOXIC EYESHADOW

Eyeshadows can also contain Parabens, phthalates, synthetic dyes, talc, aluminum, and heavy metals. All of these ingredients are unnecessary in our makeup because we have plenty of non toxic eyeshadow options to choose from!

I try to stay away from titanium dioxide in my makeup as much as possible, since it is a possible carcinogen. I find it especially difficult to find a titanium-free eyeshadow because it’s usually included to add an opaque-ness to eyeshadow shades. IF I go with an eyeshadow that includes this, I make sure it’s as low as possible in the listed ingredients. (Products ingredients are listed by highest to lowest quantity.)

Because I love a shimmer to my eyeshadow, I’ve included a few of those options below.

What I look for in a non toxic eyeshadow

I like to stick with organic products as much as possible.
It needs to be affordable. This can be tricky when it comes to eyeshadow because everyone uses it differently. I like having a minimal collection of 3-4 everyday shades, but others prefer a full palette, or single shades. How much you’re willing to spend on your favorite option varies from person to person. Because of this, I have included a variety of options below.
Must be void of toxic ingredients. Topically applied products absorb into our skin within 26 seconds. From there, they enter the bloodstream and can begin to accumulate within the body. Toxic chemical ingredients can cause anything from skin irritation to hormone imbalances. Some ingredients are even classified as carcinogenic (known to cause cancer.)

Non Toxic Eyeshadow Products:

#1) 100% PURE Pressed Powder Eye Shadow

BUY NOW

I love that these eyeshadows are fruit-pigmented, vegan, cruelty-free, gluten free, titanium-free, and made in the USA. In addition to being non toxic, the ingredients are beneficial to your skin! They include vitamins and antioxidants that can help moisturize the the skin and protect against aging. Not only does this brand eliminate the bad ingredients, but added in beneficial ones!

Available in multiple shades. Click here to view.

#2) Alima Pure | Pressed Eyeshadow Singles

BUY NOW

Alima Pure is a company with great products, but also great values. They do not test on animals, they are carbon neutral since 2008, and support renewable energy and giving back to the environment.

These eyeshadows are made in Italy. They contain avocado oil, jojoba oil and rice powder. Avocado oil is hydrating to the skin, jojoba oils stimulates collagen production, and rice powder is rich in vitamins and soothing to the skin.

Available in multiple shades. The compact is also refillable! Click here to view.

#3) Alima Pure | Loose Mineral Eyeshadow Singles

BUY NOW

Alima Pure also has single shade loose powders which can be applied as is, or with a slightly wet brush for a bolder color. These may contain titanium dioxide.

Alima Pure does not test on animals. Their products are vegan, and are free of nuts, gluten, fragrance, silicone, parabens, sulfates, synthetic dyes, phthalates, dimethicone, talc, bismuth oxychloride, and nanoparticles.

Available in multiple shades. Click here to view.

#4) Burt’s Bees 100% Natural Origin Eye Shadow Palette Trio | Dusty Woods

BUY NOW

Burt’s Bees eyeshadow is made without parabens, phthalates, SLS, petrolatum, talc, synthetic fragrances, or silicones and is not tested on animals. Burt’s Bees products are also made in the USA.

Available in multiple shades. Click here to view.

#5) Honeybee Gardens ‘Canyon Sunset’ Refillable Eye Shadow Palette

BUY NOW

Honeybee Gardens creates makeup and personal care products that are vegan, cruelty free, gluten free, paraben free, and talc free.

Their products are also vegan and celiac friendly!

They also donate to no-kill animal shelters every month. I love a company that has great products AND has values I believe in.

Honeybee Gardens has gorgeous palettes and single eyeshadows. What I love about this palette is that you can buy refills and create a customized palette for yourself. I love the shades included, but when it’s time to change it up, all I have to do is buy an individual color to place inside the palette!

Available in multiple shades. Click here to view.

Click here to view the refills you can buy to customize your palette. (Shown below)